PLUNGE INTO THE DEEP FREEZE
PLUNGE INTO THE DEEP FREEZE
Ice bathing can be wonderfully invigorating and chase away sore muscles after a workout. But does it also make you happy, slim, or immortal? A fact check with a wink.
“Have you completely lost your mind?” Your inner voice is muttering, and it leaves no room for doubt: “You’re not a penguin. And this water isn’t just fresh—it’s colder than cold. Liquid ice—help! Step in there, and it will take your breath away faster than your teeth can chatter.” Now suck in your stomach; don’t offer the enemy any more target than necessary. Every hair on your body is already standing on end, and your big toe hasn’t even touched the water yet.
Ice bathing! Some hail it as the cure-all of our ancestors. Others foresee certain demise at the mere thought of it. Either way, the community devoted to this (self-)discipline has grown considerably in recent years. Where once you spotted only the odd soul daring to wade into streams and rivers in winter—or even to lower themselves into a lake through a hole cut in the ice—today it is no longer a rare sight. They gather on the shore in droves. Sometimes with a woolly hat, sometimes without. The bath towel always their most faithful companion.
The devotees of this frosty pleasure meet in groups and regularly expose themselves to the icy inferno. They swear by its health benefits. But which of these truly exist—perhaps even scientifically proven? And which may spring from the realm of wishful thinking?
Father Sebastian Kneipp would surely have been delighted with them—even if his teachings encompassed far more than cold water. Other naturopathic traditions, too, know all manner of water treatments.
Stress Test
When you suddenly plunge into cold water, the body doesn’t switch to wellness mode—it switches to alarm. The immediate result: the sympathetic nervous system is activated, the blood vessels in the skin constrict, and heart rate and blood pressure can rise. Many people initially gasp for air or begin to hyperventilate uncontrollably. This so-called cold shock response is in fact the best-documented physical reaction to an ice bath. In other words, the body by no means mistakes the water for a spa—rather, for a well-organized emergency.
Water Versus Warmth
Water conducts heat away far better than air. That is why a bath in water at 10°C is thermally something quite different from, say, a stay in a cold chamber filled with very cold, dry air. That, too, falls broadly under cryotherapy, an umbrella term for various medical and sports-related cold applications. Depending on temperature, duration, and immersion depth, the body can continue to cool down after the initial cold shock. Hypothermia is therefore not a theoretical footnote but a real risk—even after leaving the water.
Recovery—or the Feeling of It
The best-researched benefit of cold-water therapies lies in sports. After intense exertion, cold-water immersion can reduce perceived muscle soreness and help people feel recovered more quickly. The results are not identical in every study, but this potential recovery effect is far better supported than most general wellness promises.
A more pleasant sense of your body, however, is not the same as proven performance gains. For sprinting, strength, flexibility, and other objective performance measures, the findings are more mixed. Nor does long-term training adaptation automatically improve just because you climb into ice water after every session. Particularly after strength training, regular cold exposure immediately afterward may even dampen certain adaptation processes.
Toughened Up
Those who repeatedly take brief dips in cold water can partially blunt the initial cold shock response. Breathing and cardiovascular reactions may then be less dramatic. This is a form of acclimatization—but not a free pass for ever colder, longer, or more solitary adventures. Physics, after all, does not get used to people.
Loved and Livened
Many people report feeling more alert, clear-headed, and energetic after a bath—or simply enjoying the good feeling of having gotten through something unpleasant. One study also observed a short-term decrease in negative mood and cortisol levels after a single “cold-water immersion,” as researchers call a dip in cold water. Such findings are interesting, but they are not enough to recommend ice bathing as a treatment for depression, anxiety disorders, or chronic stress. The personal high may be real; the grand therapeutic claim has yet to be proven.
Clear as Mud
Cold can alter immune and inflammatory markers. But it does not automatically follow that people get sick less often or suddenly possess a particularly formidable immune system. A few altered lab values are not yet a suit of armor against the common cold.
Happy Ever After?
Cold can be activating in the short term and lift some people’s mood—and it feels especially convincing once the cold shock subsides. Whether regular ice bathing strengthens mental health in the long run, however, has not yet been sufficiently established. For depression or anxiety disorders, an ice bath replaces neither therapy nor medical treatment.
Temperature Down, Dopamine Up?
Cold changes the body’s stress responses. But that does not justify claims of a blanket, hours-long dopamine high of some specific percentage. Anyone who feels euphoric after a bath is, of course, still welcome to enjoy it.
Cold That Melts Fat?
Cold can briefly increase energy expenditure, because the body then has to produce more heat itself. For meaningful, lasting weight loss through ice baths, however, there is still no convincing evidence.
Fit Vessels—and a Longer Life?
Cold does trigger measurable vascular and circulatory responses. But that is not the same as proven protection against cardiovascular disease, nor evidence of a longer life. A leap into cold water is a stimulus for the circulation—not a life insurance policy. Nor does the principle of “more is more” automatically apply to ice baths. Temperature, duration, immersion depth, acclimatization, and physical condition all change the strain on the body. The optimal dose has not been conclusively determined—and a dare is not yet a therapy.
Freezing, but Safely
If you’re curious and would like to try ice bathing yourself, there are a few safety tips worth heeding.
Ease In, Never Jump
The sudden cold stimulus can cause gasping and uncontrolled hyperventilation. Entering the water gradually can soften this reaction.
Never Swim Alone in Open Water
Ideally, bring along an experienced companion; entry and exit points and emergency help should also be sorted out beforehand. Slippery banks, let alone the edge of a hole in the ice, can be life-threatening.
Keep Your Head Up
Beginners in particular should not submerge completely at first. During a cold shock, gasping and uncontrolled breathing can become dangerous—so it is better to keep your airways safely above water. Submerging your face can also trigger the so-called diving reflex and put a strain on your circulation.
Go In Sober
Alcohol and other intoxicants impair perception, reaction time, and your judgment of your own limits. Hence: don’t drink and dive…
Plan Your Warm-Up
Before the bath, check that there is a safe way out. Leave warm, dry clothing in a spot sheltered from the wind.
Take Symptoms Seriously
Anyone with cardiovascular disease or circulatory disorders should consult their doctor before ice bathing. During or after the bath, the same applies to everyone: if you experience chest pain, shortness of breath, dizziness, confusion, or unusual weakness, be clear about one thing—these, like severe or persistent shivering, are not signs of exceptional willpower but warning signs. Best not to give them the cold shoulder.
Guests at the Spa & Resort Bachmair Weissach will find plenty of ways, in every season, to take on their eternally shivering inner voice. The Gumpe, a natural plunge pool in the garden, is fed by the cool water of the Mühlbach stream, which flows through the hotel grounds. Its bubbling water is more than fresh at any time of year!
The Mizu Onsen Spa has two cold-water pools: one at 10°C, the other at 2°C. They are located in the sauna area, hidden from the eyes of others. Here you can pull your frosty grimaces in complete peace and gasp for air for a moment until the first cold shock begins to ease.
And last but not least, Lake Tegernsee itself is close at hand. Even at the height of summer, its water rarely gets warmer than about 22°C. It invites you to cool off all year round; in the cooler seasons, however, it is without a doubt one of the most beautiful ice-bathing hotspots in the world—with famously spectacular views.
So in you go—but with a little care.
Text: Susanne Hermanski