Christian Muscheid, “Seattle,” 2023, acrylic on canvas

From the imaginary art trade of the Stone Age to the very real art fair: commercial galleries have always adapted to new markets and new media. Now digitalization and AI are putting their role as intermediaries to the test once again.

It is far from proven that conversations like this one ever took place in the Paleolithic:

“You give me a piece of your mammoth fillet. In return, I’ll send my brother over, the old scaredy-cat. He’ll paint you a few nice bison on your cave wall.”—“With hunters and spears?”—“He can do that, but it’ll cost you extra. One rib for three warriors.”

What is certain, however, is this: the art trade has been around for a very long time, and right now it is once again undergoing profound change—like so much else in the world in an age of advancing digitalization and the upheavals looming with AI. In the art market, too, the old business models no longer work the way they used to. And what only recently counted as a recipe for success—an international fair in the style of Art Basel, say—is already having to fight for its place.

Commercial galleries in the narrower sense only took shape in the 19th century, in Paris and London. One example is Goupil & Cie, a firm founded in Paris in 1829. It presented finished works, displayed them in its shop windows, and introduced them to an international circle of buyers through changing exhibitions. The result was a business model that permanently combined advice, marketing, and sales.

For centuries before that, things had been different. In medieval Europe, art was commissioned above all by the clergy and the nobility. Artists produced to order; a free market for finished works barely existed. Who had the resources to make and store goods that in the end perhaps no one would want—let alone goods that had to be fashioned from precious raw materials such as lapis lazuli pigments or a fine block of white marble?

The less talent an artist had for self-promotion, the more important the go-betweens probably were, even then. Yet sales took place mainly through personal networks and through the workshops in which the more or less great masters went about their work with their assistants. Most of these studios operated like large craft businesses.

In the Renaissance, especially from the 16th century on, the social order shifted. Wealthy citizens of Europe’s trading cities also wanted to show what they possessed: power, influence, beauty, education, splendor, and God’s favor. And what could express all of that better than a painting on the wall, a relief on the façade, or a sculpture in the garden? What is more, new machines had made possible not only the printing of books but also the wide distribution of art prints.

Art academies were founded. Demand grew. The first so-called galleries, however, were often still purely private collection rooms and stately halls in which their owners’ art was put on display. It was the “academies” and “salons” that eventually presented works to a wider public—and in doing so, they shaped which artists got noticed.

It is no coincidence that the aforementioned Goupil & Cie was among Vincent van Gogh’s first employers. In 1869, though, the firm was not dealing in his works. It hired him as an apprentice at its branch in The Hague. His uncle, a partner there, had arranged the position. His younger brother Theo also joined Goupil four years later. And it was Theo, of course, who later did everything he could to promote his brother as an artist—and who believed in him when hardly anyone else did.

Traditionally, gallerists support artists not only by selling their works. Their real achievement lies in discovering and exhibiting unknown talent, building long-term relationships of trust with collectors, sharing production costs, and forging contacts with museums.

In 1981, for example, the Munich gallerist Six Friedrich exhibited Anselm Kiefer, then still largely unknown. Today his works are among the most expensive by any living artist on the market. Many gallerists combine the art trade with a passion for collecting and patronage—Peggy Guggenheim, for instance, or Heinz Berggruen, who worked with Pablo Picasso, Paul Klee, and Henri Matisse.

In analog times, their work was defined by personal encounters, by looking at the works firsthand, and by the chemistry among everyone involved. The digitalization of the world has brought entirely new challenges to this market—without easing some of the old ones. These include the cost of transporting and insuring artworks, the material outlay, and the need for at least one human being to decide which works are shown.

Where and how those works are made accessible to the public, however, has already changed dramatically over the past ten years, and above all since the pandemic. Websites, digital viewing rooms, newsletters, and social media are now important platforms for making works visible. And once they are visible there, the whole world has access to them in principle—with the fatal side effect that they are copied even faster and more shamelessly than before. Just think of how the photography market has changed.

Small galleries in particular are fighting for survival today more than ever. Auction houses, artists’ own websites, and direct digital sales all compete with them. Large art fairs that travel the globe offer a setting in which galleries can present themselves in turn. But the price of shipping art to Miami, Dubai, or Shanghai and showing it there to a merry, champagne-fueled traveling circus of wealthy collectors is high. And just because someone looks enthralled doesn’t mean they have reached for their credit card.

Gallerists keep going nonetheless. They make use of the latest technologies and try out other venues and new concepts. The Spa & Resort Bachmair Weissach, too, offers an exciting example of such a development with Gallery KOKO: a gallery that keeps reinventing itself. To discover its art, all you need to do is let your gaze wander along the walls. There may be no warriors to be seen, but there is plenty of painting.

Text: Susanne Hermanski